Score 1–5 per cell, independently, before comparing notes. Judge: ______________ Date: ______________
| Criterion | Concept 1 Hallmark | Concept 2 Counterpart | Concept 3 Fair Copy |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mark Reads as a held page and as quotation marks; works at 16 px, in the rail, as a print stamp; no literal hands. | |||
| Trust Looks like something a solicitor would put in a bundle. Professional, rich colour, not corporate grey. | |||
| The four states Accepted · reply due · disputed · superseded read at a glance on the Fact page. Disputed is calm, never alarm red. Cover the colour: do the shapes still tell them apart? | |||
| Recollection marker A recollection is unmistakably not a recording, on the list and on the Fact page. | |||
| Reply window The date is a date, not a siren. | |||
| Dark mode Designed, not inverted; the states still work. | |||
| Type UI face is calm and legible at 13–15 px; the export face reads as a document. | |||
| Would you be proud to send the link Gut call. | |||
| Total | |||
| One line: what would you change about your favourite? |
Print this page or screenshot it. Totals update as you type. · Back to the concepts